Notes # 30: AccessibleEU Monitoring Reports, Dubai Hotels, Guide Dogs vs. AI Glasses...
Created while listening: Yağmur Ender – Düğüm
Personal Notes
I am using Goodreads to take notes on the books that I read and rate them. This is the most functional app that I have used because I remember every book that I rated or commented on Goodreads. The simplicity of the app is a great feature for me. However, last month something happened…
Normally, you can give a 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5-star rating to a book, but with the last update, you can give half-star, and even quarter-star ratings to a book. And this causes one of the clearest target size problems that I have ever seen. Since the last update, I always have to review my rating because I mistakenly click the wrong place. For example, when I try to click 3.5, I click 3.75. I understand the idea of giving more space to readers to express their real ratings, but please be aware of accessibility.
News
AccessibleEU’s 2025 Monitoring Reports
Source: AccessibleEU
When I write notes for the news, I generally copy the original title directly. However, for this one, I didn’t include the 'steady progress in advancing accessibility in the EU' part in the original title. AccessibleEU, which is the European Union's flagship resource centre for accessibility, has published its 2025 monitoring reports. I read the dashboards for most of the 27 EU country monitoring reports prepared by country representatives and wrote an 'In Detail' section with key takeaways that show stability instead of progress in digital accessibility. As a side note, I recommend taking a look at the dashboard for your country of interest, as the reports provide information not only on accessibility data but also on national legislation and active DPOs.
Dubai Hotels Make Strong Progress In Digital Services Accessibility
Source: Hotel & Catering
Compliance scores of Dubai hotels rose from 83% to 90%. However, in my opinion, this quantitative increase is not the main point of the article. Digital accessibility is being treated as a core strategic goal for tourism, directly supporting the objectives of the Dubai Economic Agenda D33 to double the emirate’s economy. The Department of Economy and Tourism and the Dubai Digital Authority are working in close coordination, framing accessibility primarily through the lens of 'visitor experience'. While it remains unclear whether these accessibility evaluations rely fully on automated testing tools or involve manual audits, the cross-sector collaboration, strategic prioritization, and direct engagement of the Dubai Digital Authority with businesses provide a foundation for meaningful progress.
Legally Blind Woman From Ballarat Says Smart Glasses Replaced Her Guide Dog
Source: ABC
This is a controversial article. Heidi Biggin is so happy with her smart glasses that she said 'I'd go as far as to say I wouldn't get another guide dog because of these AI glasses.' Her only concern is about people accusing her of filming them because of the lighting flash in the glasses when in use. On the other side, a representative of Guide Dogs Victoria said 'Your primary mobility aid as someone who is blind or low vision should always be a guide dog or white cane.' When persons like Heidi Biggin verbalize their comments and with the reality that in Victoria it takes nearly two years and more than $50,000 to breed, raise, and train a guide dog, I don’t know where it will go. But fully technology-dependent mobility aids are not applicable from my point of view as well.
Inspirations
Accessibility Goes Mainstream - And AI Agents Are Next
Source: ITWire
In Notes # 28, I shared a study stating AI agents work better on accessible websites and spend fewer tokens. In this article, GitHub’s head of accessibility Ed Summers touches on this issue with some examples. To gain a background in accessibility and universal design, you can read the first section for a great foundation. In the 'AI agents need understandable interfaces too' part, he mentions how AI agents are using ALT tags or heading structures in MCP servers using webpages with structured accessibility snapshots rather than taking screenshots.
Respecting Your Users’ Preferences
Source: Tempertemper
If you are thinking of adding an accessibility mode to your website, please read this article. Martin Underhill clearly explains the legal background and technical solutions to make your digital product compliant with users' contrast and motion settings via simple CSS adjustments.
The "Disability Dongle": Why Silicon Valley Hates Me And You
Source: Sightless Scribbles
This is what I need! I recommend you to read the full article. “A disability dongle is a piece of technology that is flashy, expensive, and technically impressive, but utterly fails to solve the actual problem it claims to address. (…) It is designed to win design awards, not to be used. (…) These solutions are nothing other than costumes, the height of ‘performative engineering’ (…) They will build a headset that describes the room to me (poorly), but they won't use semantic HTML headings so I can actually navigate a webpage. Why? Because semantic HTML isn't sexy.” This is the discouragement and aggression that we all have experienced from time to time, and that’s why we are here.
In Detail: Key Takeaways From The AccessibleEU 2025 Monitoring Reports
Read this article on its own page
AccessibleEU prepared its 2025 monitoring reports separately for each country. Alongside the full reports, there are short dashboard documents that summarize the findings. A dashboard is enough if you want to learn about one country. But if you want to see the big picture across the EU, you have to open each country’s document and compare them yourself. Below are the takeaways from a combined document I put together with Claude’s help. I only kept the findings on digital accessibility.
Countries have moved the EAA into national law. What about the Commission?: Every country report says the EAA requirements have been moved into national law, and that the Commission is now checking whether these laws are correct. There is no information on when the Commission will finish.
There are audits, but do they work?: All 27 countries say they carry out audits. Yet in none of the countries with available data are more than 60% of public websites and mobile apps accessible. Only 5 countries stated improvement compared to previous years.
Involving disabled people stays on paper: Only 2 countries give a concrete example of involvement of persons with disabilities in audit process. And only 9 of 27 countries make this involvement mandatory.
Complaints are recorded, but we can’t see them: 13 of the 27 countries say they record digital accessibility complaints. Only 2 share actual numbers.
Audits and awareness work, but no visible funding: 19 of the 27 countries share information about their audits, and 9 give details about awareness work. But only 2 countries give a concrete example of a budget for digital accessibility.
There is training, but is it sufficient?: All 27 countries say digital accessibility training exists. Only 8 give details about their programs, and most of these are run by public agencies. Disabled people still have little say in these trainings.
There is no common language for measuring accessibility: Some reports give the share of accessible websites, while others use the term “partially accessible.” Some go into detail about automated checks. Because the details and the wording are different, the countries can’t really be compared.
Good indicators don’t mean good results: The reports score every country on 20 shared indicators across four areas: built environment, transport, ICT and public policy. In ICT, 15 countries look compliant on at least 15 of the 20. But as shown above, websites and mobile apps are still far behind.
Discussion Corner
This issue raises a question. Pick a side, then tell me why in the comments below.
A legally blind woman says AI smart glasses have replaced her guide dog. Guide Dogs Victoria says your primary mobility aid should always be a guide dog or a white cane.
Can AI glasses replace a guide dog or a white cane?
Comments
What do you think about this issue?
Get Each Issue By Email
New notes, news and an album recommendation, straight to your inbox. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.
You will get a confirmation email first. Subscriptions are handled by Buttondown.
